Read more reviews at Yelp HERE
I’ve been here twice and I’ve got to say that I’ve enjoyed it more each time. The food, Salads, Grinders, Pasta & Thin Crust Pizza are all delicious. The Italian Grinder has Pastrami, Salami & Peperoni and is great! I also love the Red Pepper & Garlic Pasta & the Marguerite Pizza. Last night my wife and I couldn’t decide so we split a Salad, a Grinder and a Pizza. Never came close to finishing that much food but I just ate some for my lunch and its still great. If you like a little wine with your dinner they have a good selection & wine by the bottle that’s so inexpensive there’s really no reason to buy it by the glass. Really great prices. That dinner, 2 beers & 2 glasses of wine came to $46 including tax. Great food & more than fair prices. The atmosphere is casual and charming with about 6 tables inside and two on the small deck. This is a small place and last night, a Wednesday night, we saw people waiting (not long) in the overstuffed couches for a seat. Nice business for a Wednesday at 6pm. I recommend this place to anyone who wants wants a good meal! Go there! Be forewarned though… They do not accept credit or debit cards. Cash & Checks only but don’t let that stop you! Go!
James S. King, WA
I love how you can pick where you want to sit and choose to play a game while you wait or sip some great wine from a great selection. I usually get the chicken sandwich, which is AMAZING everytime! Although everything that my friends and I have tried is yummy! Once again I would choose to go here over the Black Diamond Bakery and Restaurant. I have always had great, quick service with a smile here and left with a smile on my face.
Misty N. Renton, WA.
My husband and I went here for the first time and loved it. Pizza and grinders are yummy, and the homemade cheesecake is AMAZING!! Service was great, and even the other patrons were so friendly. Good wine selection and reasonable prices. We will definitely be going back!
Laura G. Kent, WA.
I’ve now been here three times since I moved to Maple Valley. Every time has been a positive experience. I like the vintage atmosphere and the history of the building. I also enjoyed the owner’s sense humor and interaction with his customers…..The pizza I enjoyed and so did my wife and daughter (pickier than I am). Has a-lot of little toys for the kids to be entertained throughout dinner. Food and atmosphere has been excellent on all 3 occasions.
Ryan L. Maple Valley, WA.
Seriously the special of the night was one of the better dishes I have had anywhere…Period. Linguine with shrimp, peppers and romano all tossed in fresh lime it was so damn good and under 10 bucks. Couldnt eat it all either.
Joe T. Seattle, WA.
Best pizza in WA state! The pasta is also very delicious. Amazing selection of local wine.
MM Seattle, WA.
We came in (our first time) it is a very small cozy place. Loved the way you select wine. You select your wine from what they have sitting along a wall(selection is limited, but there are enough,, prices are just below each wine), bring the bottle back to your table, while waitress gets your water. She then takes it away to open and returns it to your table without pouring. Simple! We drank the bottle with our salad and a nice pizza. Waitress was friendly and courteous. The owner/cook is a nice guy,, said he would get more of the same wine we liked for the next time we come.We will be soon!
A Google User
The overall food quality here is excellent, above-and-beyond what you’d expect for the venue. A cute, quaint historic building in a small-town setting. My favorite? The confections — try the cheesecake (made in-house). I’m going to see a band there and do the wine tasting event.
Review from Menuism
Excellent food, and Mike is an amazing chef! I live pretty close by, and so every time I get a chance, I swing by. Never have I had a bad meal or experience with Black Diamond Pizza & Deli. They serve cold beer, mouth watering pizza and pasta, and while I have not yet tried the sandwiches yet, but I have heard they are amazing as well. This is a great place for lunch of dinner, and a great little spot heading back from a long day at Crystal. Both Thumbs Up!!! I would absolutely recommend it!